Bus delays, benefit review relays and BOMAD for cowboys

Top of the Charts

Afternoon all,

Alan, Stephen and John walk into a bar, and the barman says, “What’ll it be Andy?”

Alan says cut benefits. Do not be confused here (Andy) – the removal of entitlement to health and disability benefits from under 25s is expected to save half of that bill in 2036 through some individuals receiving less. Stephen’s order is imminent, but he’s been told it can’t be pricier than his last one so his options are limited. But if John was hoping for a cheap round, Alan has spent 280 pages laying bare an unsurprising reality: solving deep and long-standing challenges in society tends not to be free.

If you’ve been hiding under a rock this week it’s possible you didn’t notice Alan Milburn’s review and you might have no idea what I’m on about. He has done an incredible job at making an issue that has often languished at the bottom of the priority list a grade-A political hot topic. We are already seeing the benefits of that, from the government’s extension of the job guarantee scheme to a funded college place for every 16–18 year old who wants one. But boy does the government have some stuff to sort out this winter on its plans for benefits…(Timms review cheat sheet below)

Ofgem’s new energy price cap comes next week and our resulting Chart of The Week ain’t pretty.

Have a great weekend,

Ruth

Chief Executive
Resolution Foundation


Late again? Using bus location data, the excellent Tom Forth has built a tracker for how long bus journeys in England and Wales actually take (not Scotland, upsetting one RF colleague who tells me that Lothian Buses won Bus Operator of the Year). You can pick any two stops, and it gives you the published and average journey times against the time actually needed if you want to be on time nine journeys in ten. Self-centredly considering Westminster serving buses, the 148 from Camberwell Green needs a buffer of over 20 minutes compared to the published journey time. For commuters fed up of overly optimistic Google Maps, this is the website for you…

Trial and error. Most AI productivity studies ask how well people work with the machine, but a new NBER paper asks the more awkward question of what they can do once it’s gone. In a three-month trial 133 patent lawyers at eleven US firms were randomly given (or denied) a custom drafting assistant, with blinded expert attorneys marking all their work. AI lifted drafting quality by 0.38 standard deviations at ninety days, and narrowed the gap between juniors and seniors. But when AI was withdrawn from everyone, the lasting benefit showed up only among senior lawyers, while junior lawyers showed no average gain. Firms tempted to swap trainee hours for chatbots may find they’ve saved on juniors today and run short of seniors tomorrow.

How low can you go? Ask why the UK isn’t building enough homes and eventually an economist will point at land prices. This interesting blog offers a corrective to anyone who thinks the slump would end if only land prices would fall. Land should be valued at whatever is left once build costs and developer profit are accounted for, but with construction inflation outpacing new home values for the last few years, the residual is getting squeezed. Slower, pricier planning applications (decisions now take more than three times as long as 15 years ago) increase risk for landowners, and outside options like data centres, supermarkets and storage units make for wallet-padding alternatives. Good luck getting to those 1.5 million homes built any time soon.

Keeping it in the family. The issue of the Bank of Mum and Dad is not a new one, shows this blog. The author built a database of 20,000+ upper-class people and their familial ties in Dallas, Texas over its first 122 years until 1963. They found that nearly four-fifths were closely related in a ‘hairball’. And being in this ball paid off: where wealth, status and power were knotted together through family, more than four in five had upper-class descendants in Dallas after 1940, twice the rate for the upper class as a whole. If you’re interested in how status and connections matter as much as money, come to our event in just over a week’s time examining the earnings and mobility gaps of graduates from different socio-economic backgrounds


Something for the Weekend | Time for Timms

This week was all about Milburn; but soon it will be Timms’ turn, with the Review of Personal Independence Payment (PIP) due before the end of the month. It aims to make sure PIP is “fair and fit for the future” but spending more money is off the table, with the Review pledging to stay within the OBR’s spending forecasts.

Expect plenty of recommendations on making the current PIP system more humane. Rightly so: there’s lots of evidence the system is traumatising, with claimants describing being treated with suspicion and disdain.  For more on PIP’s pitfalls – and possible alternatives – check out our recent High Resolution episode.

Scotland shows a better approach is possible without explosive cost. Its Adult Disability Payment (ADP) replaced PIP four years ago, with the same eligibility rules and payment rates but a kinder delivery. Crucially, this has not permanently increased award rates or sizes. ADP’s award rate for new applicants was 32 per cent in the first half of 2026, lower than PIP’s 36 per cent.

The harder task comes when the Government must produce a welfare White Paper that reconciles Timms with Milburn. Yet our survey of 2,500 PIP recipients found young claimants’ conditions differ less from older claimants’ than is often assumed – 16-24-year-olds are less likely to report depression than 25-54-year-olds for example. The important thing is having the best system (our suggestions here) for all ages, rather than different conclusions driven by two very different independent processes.


Chart of the week

Next week Ofgem will announce January’s Energy Price Cap and it is set to soar by £443 to £2,166 in January (according to Cornwall Insight). This week’s chart looks at monthly dual fuel bills for typical households since 2019. The bars show bills before any government support; the diamonds show the winter of 2022-23 after the £400 discount. Once you account for the £400 Energy Bills Support Scheme discount households received in 2022-23, bills will be around £50 higher in real terms this January than they were in January 2023, at the height of the previous energy price crisis. The chart doesn’t include the £100 Household Energy Payment scheme this January or the £150 Council Tax rebate from 2022, but including them wouldn’t change the picture. We know that energy price shocks hit poorer households hardest, which is why the Government’s decision to spread limited support thinly across four-in-five households is the wrong approach. It’s those with typical or higher energy use and low incomes that will find this hardest to bear. Doubling support to half the number of households, with support based on energy use and income, would do a far better job of protecting vulnerable households this winter.