Three figures we should all pay attention to in the Milburn Review

by

It’s finally here: the Milburn Review of young people and work was published today. It’s big (over 250 pages); it’s bold (“a new settlement for the next generation”); and it’s brash (if its recommendations were implemented in full, it claims the UK would be “NEET Zero” by 2036-7).  

There are many, many numbers in the report (the best ones, naturally, are citations of Resolution Foundation research…), but just three of them taken together tell us a lot about Milburn’s recommended programme for change.  

 

£5.8 billion: Going big on youth services 

First, the report contains a dizzying array of recommendations for investment in service provision: £5.8 billion-worth in 2036-37 (in current prices). Some of this would be restitution for the austerity years (think greater further education funding); some would fund genuinely new services like a permanent youth employment scheme or support for young people with mental health problems.  

That £5.8 billion of extra support sounds like a big figure, but it still likely falls short of the level of spending we observe in the lowest NEET countries. For example, Milburn’s proposed additional £3 billion for employment support for under-25s would take the UK from being a low spender on active labour market policies for young people relative to other European countries, to roughly middle of the pack.  

And getting all these services and schemes working in concert, which is central to the Review’s vision, would also be no mean undertaking. This would require multiple departments and indeed multiple levels of government to work together to boost youth participation. Milburn recommends introducing a “Youth Opportunity Test” that applies to every government department, plus new duties on schools and local government, to achieve just this.   

 

440,000: The new New Deal will need to pack a punch 

Which leads us to the second number. The Milburn Review concludes that a combination of early intervention, improved health support, more education and training investment and active labour market policies would result in a ‘big bang’ when it comes to youth employment. By 2036-37, the Review estimates 440,000 more young people would be in employment as a result, and that this would save the state £2.4 billion in 2036-37 as higher taxes and lower benefits are paid.  

But achieving that outcome, too, may prove quite the task. Dividing the £5.8 billion of extra support by the 440,000 extra young people the report says will get into employment as a result suggests the average cost of getting each additional young person into work will be around £13,000. Sounds like a lot? It’s not. Past employment support schemes have spent around £30,000 per additional young person employed. Milburn’s £5.8 billion on employment, health and other support would have to be about three times as effective to get 440,000 additional young people into work.  

 

£3.6 billion: The scale of benefit cuts 

And finally, to number three. The Review finds that the extra spending and savings resulting from the various recommendations balance out after a decade, on the basis that there are £3.6 billion of savings from “welfare reform”, a polite term for benefit cuts achieved through restricted eligibility, lower levels and/or shorter award lengths.  

Make no mistake, these are the savings from cuts not from extra employment. And for those worried they are not tough enough, note that this is equivalent to half of the estimated £7.1 billion youth health and disability benefit bill in 2036-37 (in 2026-27 prices). And these reforms won’t just affect young people that are NEET: almost two-thirds of PIP recipients aged 16-24-years are in education or employment for example, many of whom could lose large amounts of support.   

But alongside that (very important) debate about winners and losers, there are other radical aspects of Milburn’s vision for the benefit system. The Review recommends localising large parts of the system (a new local Health and Disability Fund, for instance); the introduction of far greater discretion and simultaneous loss of statutory entitlements for young people whose health conditions are not deemed severe or long-standing; and the creation of a separate system for young people which will mean cliff edges galore when young people turn 18 and then again when they turn 25.  

 

A system that pays for itself should not be an end in itself 

In all, then, Milburn has proposed £5.8 billion of investment, £3.6 billion of benefit cuts, and believes that after a decade, higher youth employment will also save the state £2.4 billion more. Fiscal neutrality will be achieved!  

But the Review also shows the extent to which public spending has been increasingly skewed to older people over time, with the gap between spending on children and young people versus spending on pensioners widening over the past two decades. In that context, whether or not the recommendations are cost neutral is arguably the wrong test.  

What the report has shown today is that moving the dial on NEETs will require wholescale change and investment across the system. As the details are debated (and the recommendations will have to make their way through a White Paper, Budget and a Spending Review next year), that may be the most important lesson we should all take from the Milburn Review.  

 

This article was originally published on our Substack.