Brejoin would bring back uncertainty, but less than the first time around Today's summit brings welcome – if incremental – gains, as long as answers on a future trajectory are provided quickly, according to Sophie Hale. 20 November 2026 by Sophie Hale Sophie Hale At Monday’s Lord Mayor’s Banquet, Andy Burnham repeated his argument at Labour Party conference that the “hard Brexit we were given is not good enough”. But for anyone already dreaming of racing through shorter passport queues next summer, today’s EU-UK delivers a deflating reality check. Big changes will take time. What we got today was a tweak-around-the-edges deal which rests heavily on agreements predominantly negotiated by the Starmer Government, covering food and drink, emissions trading and a new youth mobility scheme. More substantial changes to the UK’s relationship with the EU won’t come until after the next general election. Nevertheless, Burnham has taken another step towards a conversation about ‘Brejoin’ (sorry) with the public, and with Europe, and is arguably signaling more ambition on Europe than any government since the referendum (or at least since Theresa May’s Government). A decade on, we can see what hard Brexit has, and has not, delivered. And with the world very changed since 2016, Burnham argues it is time to ask whether we still want to be on this trajectory. So is he right about the costs of Brexit? And would reopening the debate carry new costs? We got a broken Brexit Burnham has a point. The clearest damage from our departure is to goods trade. The value of UK goods exports fell by around £10 billion between 2019 and 2024, even as world goods exports grew by a quarter, and the UK had the largest fall in goods export volumes in the G7, as this first chart shows. Services have held up better – they made up 59 per cent of UK exports in 2024, up from 48 per cent in 2019 – but that’s from goods shrinking, rather than services growing. In fact, our services exports have only just kept pace with the rest of the G7. Add it all up and the hit to the economy may be bigger than expected before we breparted (sorry). The Office for Budget Responsibility assumes Brexit will eventually reduce productivity by around 4 per cent. We reckon GDP is already between 4 and 10 per cent lower. So what are the other options? On Monday, Burnham promised to open a discussion “about options for our long-term relationship” with the EU. The European Commission President seemed open to that at today’s press conference, but their joint statement is careful to make no official commitments. UK in a Changing Europe set out the options in June with its ‘staircase‘: from a ‘TCA-minus’ Brexit, through a customs union, a Swiss-style deal and single market (EEA) membership, all the way up to rejoining. Each step up means closer alignment with EU rules, and, on the higher steps, free movement of people, in return for bigger economic gains. We’ve spent the past couple of years negotiating our way from the TCA to the ‘TCA-plus’ step, with a deal on food standards, emissions trading and youth mobility announced today. And while HMT estimates this could add a welcome half a per cent to GDP, Labour’s manifesto red lines have kept the higher steps out of reach. But Burnham wants to put those higher steps back on the table. What would reopening the question cost? Putting rejoin back on the agenda isn’t necessarily free. The uncertainty created by the vote to leave the EU in 2016 held back business investment: on one recent estimate, uncertainty explained most of a 12 per cent shortfall in business investment, relative to a world without Brexit, by 2023-24. But round two should hurt far less. It’s hard to fully separate the effects of higher uncertainty and a weaker economic outlook on investment. In 2016, the two arrived together and spurred each other on. This time, uncertainty would come with the prospect of better access to EU markets, which should partly offset it. And if talks failed, the fallback would be the status quo rather than a cliff edge, and firms already know how EU rules work – meaning the overall level of uncertainty should be lower too. Credible commitments to improved market access can also pay off quickly. China’s entry to the World Trade Organization, which removed the threat of higher US tariffs, accounted for over a third of the growth in China’s exports to the US in 2000-05, a period in which they more than doubled. That said, a long, open-ended process should still be avoided. Rejoining would require both a domestic mandate and the agreement of all 27 member states, AND firms and our EU partners would need to be convinced that it would survive a change of government. The key lesson we should take from the post-Brexit years is that what held back investment wasn’t only where the UK was heading, but how long we took to figure it out.